29 Examiners Available Now — Contact Them DirectlyNo Booking Fee — You Pay Your Examiner Directly270+ Testing Locations Across the U.S., Canada & UKFree Polygraph Research Database — 44,000+ StudiesWe Promote Clear Standards & Best Practice in Private Polygraph TestingLearning Center — Independent Guides to Every Type of Polygraph TestSame-Day Verbal Result · Written Report Within 48 HoursVetted Examiners Trained at Accredited Polygraph Schools100% Confidential — Private, Appointment-Only TestingPolygraph Glossary (600+ Terms), Book Library & School DirectoryTrusted by 10,000+ Clients, Attorneys & Organizations
LieDetectorTest.com Stop guessing. Get the truth.
Research ledger
Information Does Not Affect the Validity of a Comparison Question Test

Home › Polygraph Research › Information Does Not Affect the Validity of a…

Catalogue entry · Countermeasures Research

Information Does Not Affect the Validity of a Comparison Question Test

Wendy R. Alloway — Legal and Criminological Psychology,

2007Published
40 participantsSample size
1References here
1Cited by
Key findings

Providing examinees with detailed CQT information and countermeasure instructions did not significantly affect test validity; moreover, self-reported countermeasure use was associated with a lower (not higher) probability of a truthful classification, the opposite of what critics predicted.

Abstract

This 2007 study by Honts and Alloway investigated whether providing examinees with detailed information about the Comparison Question Test (CQT) — including countermeasure instructions widely available on the internet — would compromise the validity of the Test for Espionage and Sabotage (TES), a directed lie CQT variant. Using a mock crime paradigm with 40 participants across four groups, the researchers found no significant effect of information provision on test validity, and counter-intuitively found that reported countermeasure use was associated with a lower probability of truthfulness.

Methodology

A controlled laboratory analog study using 40 participants randomly assigned to guilty, guilty-informed, innocent, or innocent-informed conditions, with informed participants given a book detailing CQT mechanics and countermeasures for one week prior to undergoing the Test for Espionage and Sabotage (TES).

Detailed summary

This laboratory study addressed concerns that internet availability of polygraph information and countermeasures might undermine CQT validity. Forty participants were assigned to guilty/innocent conditions and half received detailed information about CQT mechanics and countermeasures one week before testing. Using the Test for Espionage and Sabotage (TES), a directed lie variant of the CQT, researchers found no significant difference in test accuracy between informed and uninformed groups. The findings suggest that readily available information about polygraph procedures does not pose an existential threat to CQT validity in controlled conditions.

Implications for polygraph practice

Results provide reassurance that public availability of polygraph information may not significantly compromise test validity, though further research in operational settings would strengthen these conclusions for real-world applications.

Comprehensive study analysis

An in-depth, original analysis of this research study's methodology, findings, and significance for the polygraph profession.

Background & Context

The rise of the internet in the late 1990s and early 2000s introduced a pressing concern for polygraph practitioners and researchers alike: what happens when examinees arrive at the testing room already armed with detailed knowledge about how the test works? Websites and online forums began disseminating information about the mechanics of the Comparison Question Test (CQT), including instructions for potential countermeasures — techniques purportedly capable of defeating the test.

Critics of polygraph science argued that this freely available information represented an existential threat to the validity of CQT-based examinations. Detailed information about the comparison question test (CQT) and possible countermeasures had become available on the Internet, raising the question of whether providing such information would affect the validity of the Test for Espionage and Sabotage (TES), a directed lie variant of the CQT. If informed examinees could systematically exploit their knowledge to produce false negatives, the practical utility of polygraph testing in security and criminal contexts would be seriously undermined.

This 2007 study by Charles R. Honts and Wendy R. Alloway, both of Boise State University, was designed to directly test this concern under controlled laboratory conditions. It contributes to a broader tradition of research on CQT robustness, sitting alongside work on countermeasures by Honts and colleagues dating back to the 1980s and 1990s. The study is particularly notable for employing the Test for Espionage and Sabotage (TES), a directed lie CQT format used in high-stakes federal screening contexts.

Research Design & Methodology

Forty participants were divided into four equal groups — guilty, guilty informed, innocent, and innocent informed. During a first appointment, participants either did or did not commit a mock crime; then some were provided with a book containing detailed information on the CQT, including possible countermeasures. After one week with the book, all participants were administered a CQT during their second appointment. Following the polygraph, participants responded to a questionnaire that asked them about their behaviour and perceptions during their examination.

The two-session design is a key methodological strength. The one-week interval between receiving the information and undergoing the examination gave participants a realistic opportunity to study the material and formulate strategies — mirroring how a real-world examinee might prepare. Key design elements include:

  • N = 40 participants, split into four equal groups of 10 (guilty, guilty informed, innocent, innocent informed)
  • Mock crime paradigm used to create genuine guilty/innocent status
  • Test for Espionage and Sabotage (TES) — a directed lie variant of the CQT administered at session two
  • One-week exposure period to a book detailing CQT mechanics and countermeasures for the "informed" conditions
  • Post-test debriefing questionnaire assessing self-reported behavior and perceptions during the exam

The inclusion of both an informed-guilty and an informed-innocent condition is methodologically important: it allows researchers to assess whether information differentially affects the test's ability to correctly classify each group, rather than simply looking at overall accuracy. Statistical analyses examined the effect of information provision on test validity outcomes, and the debriefing questionnaire data were used to interrogate the theoretical underpinnings of the CQT.

Results & Key Findings

The central finding was unambiguous: providing detailed information about the CQT — including countermeasure instructions — did not significantly reduce the validity of the test. Even after participants had access to a book containing detailed information on the CQT, including possible countermeasures, the test's discriminatory power between guilty and innocent participants was maintained.

Key findings from the study include:

  • No significant effect of information on overall CQT validity — informed and uninformed groups produced statistically comparable results
  • Countermeasure use backfired: self-reported use of countermeasures was associated with a lower probability of truthfulness for those who attempted them
  • Debriefing questionnaire results supported the theoretical predictions of the CQT, validating the psychological assumptions underlying the test format
  • The outcome for informed-guilty participants did not differ meaningfully from uninformed-guilty participants, suggesting knowledge of the test structure did not help guilty individuals escape detection

Concerns that readily available information will enable guilty individuals to produce false-negative errors seem unfounded. Strikingly, studies involving examinees who were knowledgeable or informed about polygraph methodologies have reported effect sizes for test accuracy that are similar to other studies with more naive examinees. The countermeasure finding is particularly provocative: rather than helping guilty subjects pass, attempting countermeasures appeared to be a marker — or even a cause — of physiologically detectable responses.

Discussion & Significance

The results carry significant implications for how the polygraph community responds to the widespread availability of anti-polygraph information online. A common argument among polygraph skeptics has been that posting countermeasure instructions freely on the internet renders the CQT effectively useless in an informed society. Honts and Alloway (2007) reported effect sizes for test accuracy that are similar to other studies with more naive examinees, which directly contradicts the claim that test-naive examinees are uniquely required for valid results.

Perhaps the most theoretically interesting result is the finding regarding countermeasures. The study's authors note that the reported use of countermeasures was associated with a lower probability of truthfulness — precisely the opposite of what critics predicted. This suggests that cognitive and physical efforts to manipulate the polygraph may themselves generate the kind of heightened physiological arousal that the test is designed to detect, effectively making countermeasure attempts self-defeating for guilty examinees.

The debriefing questionnaire data also offer rare insight into the psychological experience of the examination. The finding that questionnaire responses supported CQT theory suggests that examinees' internal states during testing — their differential concern about relevant versus comparison questions — unfold as the theory predicts, even when they have been explicitly told how the test functions and how to try to defeat it.

Limitations & Considerations

Several important constraints on interpretation should be acknowledged:

  • Small sample size (N = 40; 10 per cell) limits statistical power and the precision of effect size estimates; replication with larger samples is warranted
  • Laboratory analog design — mock crimes lack the emotional and motivational stakes of real criminal or security investigations, potentially limiting generalizability to field settings
  • Self-selected information exposure — participants given the book may have varied substantially in how carefully they studied it, introducing uncontrolled variability in the "informed" manipulation
  • Self-report countermeasure data rely on participants' honest disclosure post-test, which may be incomplete or inaccurate
  • The study uses the TES directed lie format specifically; findings may not fully generalize to other CQT variants or to the Relevant-Irrelevant test

It is also worth noting the study was published as a relatively brief article (pp. 311–312 in the journal), which means the reporting of statistical detail may be condensed. The small cell sizes of 10 per group also mean that individual outliers could have a meaningful influence on group-level outcomes.

Practical Applications

For polygraph examiners working in national security, law enforcement, and pre-employment screening contexts, this research provides meaningful reassurance. The Test for Espionage and Sabotage — used extensively in federal security screening — appears resistant to the kind of information-based defeat strategies that critics have suggested the internet now makes widely accessible. Examiners do not need to assume that an internet-literate examinee is capable of beating the test simply by having read about it.

For consumers and policy-makers, the countermeasure finding is especially instructive: attempting to deliberately manipulate physiological responses during a polygraph exam may actually increase the likelihood of a deceptive outcome classification, not decrease it. This finding reinforces the practical wisdom that the most effective approach for a truthful examinee is simply to respond honestly and cooperatively — and that strategies aimed at defeating the test are more likely to harm than help those who attempt them.

Read the original study

The analysis above is original editorial content based on our review of this research. For the complete study including full data, methodology details, and author discussion, access the original publication below.

References in our database [1]

Studies cited by this paper that are available in our research database.

Cited by [1]

Other studies in our database that reference this paper.

Related research

Other studies in this category that may be of interest.

Join Our Examiner Network

APA-trained examiners using validated techniques can apply to join the LieDetectorTest.com network.

Apply now →

Keep reading the ledger.

Every peer-reviewed study on polygraph and deception detection we track — catalogued, searchable and citable.

Need to book now? Our online booking system is open 24/7. Speak directly with our team about your test or booking.