Home › Polygraph Research › Psychopathy and detection of deception in a prison…
Catalogue entry · Comparison Question Test (CQT)
Psychopathy and detection of deception in a prison population
Raskin, D.C., Hare, R.D. — Psychophysiology,
100% of guilty subjects (both psychopaths and nonpsychopaths) were correctly identified using the CQT, with 91% accuracy for innocent subjects. Psychopaths showed equivalent physiological responsivity to nonpsychopaths, contradicting beliefs that they could beat the polygraph.
Abstract
This landmark 1978 study by Raskin and Hare tested whether psychopathic individuals could evade polygraph detection. Using 48 Canadian prisoners divided equally into psychopathic and nonpsychopathic groups in a mock crime paradigm, the research examined Control Question Test effectiveness across personality types.
Methodology
Mock crime laboratory study with 48 male prisoners (24 psychopathic, 24 nonpsychopathic) randomly assigned to guilty or innocent conditions. Blind examiner conducted CQT examinations measuring electrodermal, respiratory, and cardiovascular responses, scored both quantitatively and using traditional chart interpretation.
Detailed summary
The Raskin and Hare study addressed whether psychopaths could circumvent polygraph testing by virtue of their presumed emotional detachment and lack of anxiety during deception. Using a rigorous 2×2 factorial design with 48 prisoners divided by psychopathy diagnosis and mock crime guilt status, researchers administered blind Control Question Test examinations with multiple physiological channels. Results showed no qualitative differences between psychopathic and non-psychopathic groups: guilty subjects achieved 100% detection accuracy, and innocent subjects were correctly classified at 91%, with equivalent physiological responsivity across both groups. Both quantitative and traditional chart scoring methods yielded consistent findings, supporting the CQT's theoretical foundation that deception produces measurable physiological arousal regardless of personality type.
Implications for polygraph practice
These findings provide empirical evidence that the polygraph's effectiveness is not undermined by psychopathic personality traits, supporting continued use of CQT with forensic populations and challenging clinical assumptions about psychopathy and deception detection. The work strengthened theoretical confidence in physiological arousal models of deception and informed subsequent clinical and correctional polygraph applications.
Comprehensive study analysis
An in-depth, original analysis of this research study's methodology, findings, and significance for the polygraph profession.
Background & Context
The 1978 Raskin and Hare study emerged at a critical juncture in polygraph research, addressing one of the most controversial questions in deception detection: Can psychopaths "beat" the lie detector? Clinical lore and anecdotal evidence had long suggested that individuals with psychopathic personality traits—characterized by shallow affect, lack of remorse, and emotional detachment—might be immune to polygraph testing due to their presumed inability to experience anxiety when lying.
This belief had profound implications for criminal justice, as the purpose of the study was to assess the effectiveness of the Control Question Test in detecting deception with psychopaths when standard physiological measures are used. The research brought together two leading scientists: David Raskin, a pioneer in polygraph psychophysiology, and Robert Hare, who would later develop the widely-used Psychopathy Checklist. Their collaboration represented a rigorous attempt to test whether the polygraph's theoretical foundation—that deception produces measurable physiological arousal—applied to a population thought to lack normal emotional responses.
Research Design & Methodology
A sample of 48 Canadian prisoners was divided into two equal groups, one diagnosed psychopathic, with each group then randomly divided into two halves, one 'guilty' and one 'innocent' (the 'guilty' had taken $20 in a mock crime). This 2x2 factorial design allowed direct comparison of detection accuracy across psychopathy status and ground truth guilt.
The diagnostic rigor was notable for the era. Psychopathy classification likely relied on clinical assessment methods that would later inform Hare's systematic checklist development. The mock crime paradigm created ecologically valid conditions while maintaining experimental control over actual guilt or innocence.
An examiner with no knowledge of subject guilt or innocence conducted a field-type interview followed by a Control Question-polygraph examination, and quantitative and field (semiobjective) evaluations of electrodermal, respiratory, and cardiovascular activities were then made. Key methodological features included:
- Blind examiner unaware of participants' diagnostic status or guilt
- Standard Control Question Test (CQT) format mimicking real-world practice
- Multiple physiological channels: skin conductance, respiration patterns, and cardiovascular responses
- Dual scoring approach: objective quantitative analysis and traditional chart interpretation
Results & Key Findings
The results directly challenged the prevailing assumption about psychopaths and polygraph testing. Study findings did not support the belief that techniques to detect deception are ineffective with psychopaths since (1) no 'guilty' subject produced a truthful response to the Control Question Test, and (2) psychopaths were as responsive to the physiological measures as nonpsychopaths.
Specific accuracy rates were impressive for the era:
- 100% of guilty subjects (both psychopaths and nonpsychopaths) were correctly identified—no guilty person beat the test
- 91% of innocent subjects were correctly classified (based on subsequent follow-up research)
- Psychopathic and nonpsychopathic groups showed equivalent physiological responsivity to relevant and control questions
- Both quantitative scoring and traditional chart evaluation yielded similar results
The physiological data revealed no qualitative differences in how psychopaths responded to deception, contrary to theoretical predictions. Both groups exhibited heightened electrodermal, respiratory, and cardiovascular responses to relevant questions when guilty, supporting the CQT's differential arousal theory.
Discussion & Significance
The findings had immediate theoretical and practical implications. They suggested that psychopaths, despite their emotional deficits, still exhibited measurable physiological arousal when lying about salient matters. The authors proposed an alternative interpretation: rather than reflecting anxiety, physiological responses in psychopaths might stem from cognitive effort or what they termed "duping delight"—the pleasure or excitement derived from successful deception.
The study sparked vigorous debate. Lykken (1978) challenged the research, asserting or implying that the control question lie test is extraordinarily accurate, that this high accuracy can be achieved by objective scoring of the polygraph charts, and that the experiment shows psychopaths can no more "beat" the lie detector than non-psychopaths—claims Lykken found untenable. This exchange highlighted fundamental disagreements about polygraph validity and the nature of psychophysiological responding in deception.
The research influenced subsequent polygraph studies with special populations and contributed to evolving theories about the mechanisms underlying deception detection. It demonstrated that clinical personality characteristics don't necessarily predict polygraph outcomes, challenging simplistic assumptions about who can or cannot be tested effectively.
Limitations & Considerations
Several methodological constraints limit generalizability. The mock crime scenario, while controlled, lacked the genuine stakes of real criminal investigation. Critics noted the absence of realistic threat—participants faced no actual consequences for detection. The study was challenged on grounds that the polygraph testing situation lacked a 'realistic threat component, and the examiner's decisions were not based on blind chart analyses, though the authors maintained examiner blindness to diagnostic status.
Additional limitations include:
- Small sample size (24 per diagnostic group) limiting statistical power
- Laboratory setting reducing ecological validity compared to field examinations
- Psychopathy assessment methods predating modern standardized instruments
- Exclusive focus on male prisoners, restricting generalizability
- Single mock crime scenario limiting assessment of response consistency
Practical Applications
For polygraph examiners, the study provided reassurance that standard CQT procedures could be applied to individuals with psychopathic traits without necessarily compromising accuracy. This finding supported the continued use of polygraph testing across diverse populations in criminal investigations and security screening contexts.
However, the theoretical debate the study ignited underscores the importance of understanding what polygraph responses actually measure. Whether arousal stems from fear, cognitive effort, or duping delight may matter less for practical detection accuracy than for understanding the test's psychological mechanisms and limitations. Consumers of polygraph evidence should recognize that while psychopathy may not provide immunity to detection, the absence of anxiety-based responding raises questions about the test's theoretical foundations that remain debated today.
The analysis above is original editorial content based on our review of this research. For the complete study including full data, methodology details, and author discussion, access the original publication below.
Related research
Other studies in this category that may be of interest.
POLYGRAPH TECHNIQUES OF COMPARISON QUESTIONS: THEORY AND PRACTICE OF RESEARCH, PROSPECTS OF…
[002] (2023)The Primacy Position of the Comparison Question
[003] (2021)Fallacies in the estimation of the validity of the Comparison Question Polygraph…
[004] (2021)From a Rigid Cover to an Elastic One Via a Blanket too…
[005] (2019)Rebuttal: The CQT Has Scientific Support
[006] (2019)Basic vs. Applied Psychology perspectives lead to different implications from the same…
Join Our Examiner Network
APA-trained examiners using validated techniques can apply to join the LieDetectorTest.com network.
Keep reading the ledger.
Every peer-reviewed study on polygraph and deception detection we track — catalogued, searchable and citable.

