Home › Polygraph Research › Countermeasures and Credibility Assessment
Catalogue entry · Countermeasures Research
Countermeasures and Credibility Assessment
Charles Robert Honts — In Raskin, Honts & Kircher (Eds.), Credibility Assessment: Scientific Research and Applications, Academic Press,
Updated review of countermeasure research including developments since the 2003 NRC report. Discussed cognitive load as a factor in countermeasure resistance.
Abstract
Updated review of countermeasure research including developments since the 2003 NRC report.
Methodology
Experimental study examining the effects of countermeasure strategies on polygraph detection accuracy.
Detailed summary
Published in 2014 in In Raskin, Honts & Kircher (Eds.), Credibility Assessment: Scientific Research and Applications, Academic Press, this work by Honts and colleagues examined countermeasures and credibility assessment. Key findings include: Updated review of countermeasure research including developments since the 2003 NRC report. Discussed cognitive load as a factor in countermeasure resistance. Understanding countermeasure vulnerability is essential for maintaining the integrity of polygraph testing programs.
Implications for polygraph practice
Ongoing countermeasure research continues to develop both defensive (detection) and offensive (resistance) capabilities, maintaining the arms race between countermeasure users and test developers.
Comprehensive study analysis
An in-depth, original analysis of this research study's methodology, findings, and significance for the polygraph profession.
Background & Context
The 2014 chapter "Countermeasures and Credibility Assessment" represents a critical reassessment of polygraph vulnerability more than a decade after the landmark 2003 National Research Council report raised serious concerns about the detectability and effectiveness of countermeasures. This work addresses countermeasure developments in the post-NRC era, examining both published laboratory studies showing countermeasure effectiveness and the persistent inadequacy of current detection efforts. The timing was crucial—as polygraph testing expanded in national security and employment screening contexts, the threat posed by trained countermeasures demanded systematic evaluation.
Honts' chapter fills a significant gap by providing a taxonomy of polygraph countermeasures to organize the scientific literature, moving beyond scattered individual studies to create a comprehensive framework for understanding how examinees manipulate credibility assessment tests. The fundamental premise is that countermeasures are anything a person might do to defeat or distort a test, and any test where subjects have something to gain or lose faces potential vulnerability from deliberate manipulation.
Research Design & Methodology
This work is a comprehensive literature review rather than a new empirical study, systematically analyzing countermeasure research published since the 2003 NRC report. Honts organized the scientific literature using a taxonomy of polygraph countermeasures, focusing on studies demonstrating effectiveness and examining whether hands-on training is needed for countermeasure success. The review examined multiple types of countermeasures including physical techniques, mental strategies, and spontaneous efforts.
The chapter drew heavily on empirical research from Honts' laboratory and others, including:
- Laboratory mock-crime experiments with trained countermeasure groups versus controls
- Studies examining both physical countermeasures (tongue biting, toe pressing) and mental countermeasures (mental arithmetic)
- Research on spontaneous countermeasures used without training
- Detection accuracy studies assessing examiners' ability to identify countermeasure use
The review synthesized findings across different testing contexts and examined current efforts to deter or detect polygraph countermeasures, evaluating both the offensive capabilities of countermeasure users and defensive capabilities of detection methods.
Results & Key Findings
Trained countermeasures demonstrated substantial effectiveness in defeating polygraph tests. Research showed that both mental and physical countermeasures were equally effective, with each enabling approximately 50% of subjects to defeat the polygraph test. This represented a dramatic degradation from typical accuracy rates, transforming a test with generally strong validity into one performing barely better than chance.
The review confirmed that while published studies showed some countermeasures are effective in laboratory studies, hands-on training appears needed for effectiveness, and current efforts to deter or detect polygraph countermeasures appear to be inadequate. Key empirical findings discussed include:
- Cardiovascular measures most vulnerable: The strongest countermeasure effects were observed in cardiovascular measures
- Poor detection rates: Countermeasures were difficult to detect either instrumentally or through observation
- Training requirement: Spontaneous countermeasures used without training were largely ineffective for guilty subjects
- Widespread attempts: Studies found that 82.3% of guilty subjects and 42.7% of innocent subjects attempted spontaneous countermeasures
The chapter introduced cognitive load as an emerging factor in understanding countermeasure resistance. Cognitive load was found to be significantly higher for deceptive subjects during relevant questions, influencing their physiological responses, while truth-tellers experience higher load during comparison questions. This theoretical framework helped explain why using countermeasures during an already cognitively demanding deception scenario might overtax mental resources.
Discussion & Significance
The chapter's most troubling conclusion was that the countermeasure problem identified by the 2003 NRC report had not been adequately addressed. Polygraph tests were shown to be vulnerable to countermeasures in experiments, though the frequency and effectiveness of countermeasures in field practice remains anecdotal. This knowledge gap presented a critical challenge for operational polygraph programs making high-stakes decisions.
Honts emphasized that vulnerability to countermeasures is common to all tests where subjects have something to gain or lose from outcomes, and the CQT is not unique in this regard—this vulnerability should no more eliminate the CQT from applied use than it would any IQ test, personality test, or other psychological assessment. This contextualization attempted to normalize the countermeasure problem while acknowledging its seriousness.
The cognitive load discussion represented a theoretical advance, suggesting that increasing the cognitive demands of testing might serve as a countermeasure-countermeasure. If deceptive examinees must allocate cognitive resources both to maintaining their deception and executing countermeasures, this dual-task load might degrade countermeasure effectiveness or create detectable patterns.
Limitations & Considerations
The review acknowledged several critical limitations in the countermeasure literature. Most significantly, the CQT was shown vulnerable to countermeasures in experiments, but the frequency and effectiveness of countermeasures in field practice remains anecdotal, making this an area where additional research is needed. Laboratory studies may not capture the full stakes and pressures of real-world testing scenarios.
Additional concerns include:
- Training methods in research studies may not reflect how real countermeasure users prepare
- Research subjects have limited incentive compared to actual examinees facing serious consequences
- Detection method effectiveness may vary substantially based on examiner training and vigilance
- The taxonomy approach, while organizationally useful, may not capture emerging or hybrid countermeasure techniques
Evidence suggests that some countermeasures used by innocent examinees can actually increase their chances of appearing deceptive, creating a complex risk calculation that may deter countermeasure use in some populations.
Practical Applications
For polygraph examiners, this chapter provided a sobering assessment: Research has consistently shown that polygraph examiners are very poor at detecting the use of trained countermeasures, either from observing the subject during the examination or from examination of the resulting data. This necessitates development of more sophisticated detection methods, possibly including specialized sensors, statistical algorithms, or procedural modifications that increase cognitive load.
For polygraph program administrators and users of test results, the findings suggest caution in high-stakes applications where motivated examinees might access countermeasure training. The chapter reinforces the importance of using polygraph as one element in comprehensive assessments rather than as a standalone determinant. The cognitive load framework suggests that interview protocols increasing mental demands—such as unanticipated questions or strategic evidence disclosure—may offer some protection against countermeasures, though this approach requires further validation.
The analysis above is original editorial content based on our review of this research. For the complete study including full data, methodology details, and author discussion, access the original publication below.
Cited by [1]
Other studies in our database that reference this paper.
Related research
Other studies in this category that may be of interest.
The effects of mental countermeasures on psychophysiological memory detection: Facilitating orientation is…
[002] (2022)The effect of mental countermeasures on a novel brain‐based feedback concealed information…
[003] (2019)Frequent Countermeasure Usage by Narcissistic Examinees in the Concealed Information Test
[004] (2018)James Q. Murdoch: How to Pass a Polygraph, San Bernardino 2018, 23…
[005] (2018)The effect of countermeasures against the reaction time based concealed information test…
[006] (2016)Influence of countermeasures on the validity of the Concealed Information Test
Join Our Examiner Network
APA-trained examiners using validated techniques can apply to join the LieDetectorTest.com network.
Keep reading the ledger.
Every peer-reviewed study on polygraph and deception detection we track — catalogued, searchable and citable.

