Home › Polygraph Research › Detection of Subjects Employing Directed Countermeasures on the…
Catalogue entry · Countermeasures Research
Detection of Subjects Employing Directed Countermeasures on the Comparison Question Test
Charles Robert Honts — Legal and Criminological Psychology,
Investigated whether countermeasure use could itself be detected. Found that some countermeasure behaviors produced distinctive physiological patterns detectable by experienced examiners.
Abstract
Investigation of whether countermeasure use produces distinctive physiological patterns detectable by experienced examiners.
Methodology
Laboratory study examining whether countermeasure use creates detectable physiological artifacts.
Detailed summary
Published in 2002 in Legal and Criminological Psychology, 7, 105–114, this work by Honts and colleagues examined this topic area. Key findings include: Investigated whether countermeasure use could itself be detected. Found that some countermeasure behaviors produced distinctive physiological patterns detectable by experienced examiners. Understanding countermeasure vulnerability is essential for maintaining the integrity of polygraph testing programs.
Implications for polygraph practice
The possibility of detecting countermeasure use provides an additional layer of security, though examiners should not rely solely on artifact detection.
Comprehensive study analysis
An in-depth, original analysis of this research study's methodology, findings, and significance for the polygraph profession.
Background & Context
The vulnerability of polygraph examinations to countermeasures has long represented one of the most significant threats to the integrity of deception detection testing. Research has demonstrated that both mental and physical countermeasures can enable approximately 50% of deceptive subjects to defeat polygraph tests, with countermeasures proving difficult to detect either instrumentally or through observation. This creates a critical security concern, particularly in high-stakes settings like national security screening and criminal investigations where the consequences of undetected deception are severe.
Against this backdrop, the question of whether countermeasure use itself produces distinctive physiological signatures became paramount. If examiners could identify when someone was employing countermeasures—even if they couldn't necessarily overcome their effects—this would provide an additional layer of protection for polygraph programs. The research examining countermeasure detectability emerged during a period when polygraph use was expanding in government security applications, making the development of counter-countermeasure strategies increasingly urgent.
Previous research had established that examiners using separate EMG (electromyographic) analysis were able to detect the use of physical countermeasures 80 percent of the time, suggesting some countermeasure behaviors might leave detectable traces. However, there is no evidence that mental countermeasures are detectable by examiners, highlighting the differential detectability of various countermeasure types.
Research Design & Methodology
The body of countermeasure detection research employed laboratory mock-crime paradigms with participants assigned to guilty or innocent conditions. Studies examined 120 subjects recruited from the general community who were given polygraph tests by examiners using field techniques, with 80 guilty subjects trained in either physical countermeasures (biting the tongue or pressing toes to the floor) or mental countermeasures (counting backward by 7). This design allowed researchers to systematically evaluate both countermeasure effectiveness and detectability.
Key methodological elements included:
- Recording of multiple physiological channels including cardiovascular measures, electrodermal activity, and respiration patterns
- Use of experienced field examiners who evaluated charts both with and without specialized detection techniques
- Implementation of EMG monitoring to detect muscle movements associated with physical countermeasures
- Comparison of examiner judgments with objective instrumental indicators of countermeasure activity
Studies involved very short periods of training and examined countermeasure effectiveness in both comparison question and concealed information test formats, with physical countermeasures generally proving more effective than mental ones. The research program systematically varied countermeasure types, training intensity, and detection methods to map the full landscape of countermeasure vulnerability and detectability.
Results & Key Findings
Countermeasure effectiveness was substantial: Both mental and physical countermeasures enabled approximately 50% of subjects to defeat the polygraph test, with the strongest countermeasure effects observed in cardiovascular measures. This represented a dramatic reduction in detection accuracy compared to control conditions.
Key findings on detectability included:
- Limited observational detection: Countermeasures were difficult to detect either instrumentally or through observation using standard examination procedures
- EMG shows promise: Examiners using separate EMG analysis were able to detect countermeasure use 80 percent of the time for physical countermeasures
- Mental countermeasures undetectable: There is no evidence that mental countermeasures are detectable by examiners, representing a critical vulnerability
- Respiratory signatures unreliable: Judgments of both respiratory artifacts and countermeasures had low reliability, with breathing instructions resulting in a greater proportion of reports of artifacts and countermeasures
While the false negative rate for countermeasure subjects reached 78 percent, evidence suggests that deceptive subjects who use physical countermeasures and can distinguish nonrelevant from relevant questions can substantially increase their chances of avoiding detection. The challenge lies in developing detection methods that don't produce excessive false positives while maintaining sensitivity to actual countermeasure use.
Discussion & Significance
The research reveals a troubling asymmetry: while countermeasures can be highly effective at defeating polygraph tests, the ability to reliably detect their use remains limited. This creates a significant vulnerability for polygraph programs, particularly because the proportion of subjects who attempt to use countermeasures could be substantial, with many "innocent" examinees also claiming to use countermeasures in an effort to produce favorable outcomes. The motivation to use countermeasures exists across both guilty and innocent populations, though for different reasons.
The finding that EMG monitoring shows promise for detecting physical countermeasures represents an important advance, but while motion sensors and EMG detectors can be effective in detecting specific types of countermeasures, their general validity and utility remain a matter for conjecture. More problematically, mental countermeasures appear essentially undetectable with current methods, yet may be equally or more effective than physical techniques. Guilty individuals can readily defeat a CQT when briefly instructed how to do so by covertly enhancing responses to control questions through mental arithmetic or other mental maneuvers that are undetectable.
This research fundamentally challenges the polygraph community's public assertions about countermeasure detectability. While polygraph operators publicly claim that countermeasures are ineffective and easily detectable, documents reveal that behind closed doors, they admit countermeasures can be effective and are difficult to detect. This disconnect between public claims and research evidence raises important questions about the transparency and integrity of polygraph practice.
Limitations & Considerations
Several important limitations to countermeasure research merit consideration: all studies have involved mock crimes and most use experimenters or research assistants as polygraph examiners. This laboratory context may not fully capture the psychological pressure and motivation present in real-world high-stakes examinations, potentially either overestimating or underestimating both countermeasure effectiveness and detectability.
Additional limitations include:
- Available research does not address the issue of training examiners to detect countermeasures, leaving open whether specialized training might improve detection rates
- Studies typically involve brief countermeasure training, whereas real-world adversaries might practice extensively
- Detection accuracy may vary considerably across different types of countermeasures and individual differences in physiological reactivity
- The focus on detection may divert attention from prevention strategies and test design modifications that could reduce countermeasure effectiveness
Evidence indicates that some countermeasures used by innocent examinees can actually increase their chances of appearing deceptive, creating risks for truthful individuals who attempt to manipulate their responses. This highlights the complex interplay between countermeasure knowledge, application skill, and outcomes.
Practical Applications
For polygraph examiners, these findings emphasize that artifact detection should not be relied upon as the primary defense against countermeasures. While EMG monitoring may aid in detecting some physical countermeasures, examiners must recognize the fundamental limitations of current detection methods. Under some circumstances polygraph countermeasures have been found to be effective, particularly when examinees receive special training and feedback, though most spontaneous attempts are crude and ineffective. This suggests that the greatest threat comes from informed, trained individuals rather than naive attempts at manipulation.
For consumers and policymakers, the research indicates that polygraph results should be interpreted with appropriate caution, particularly in high-stakes contexts where examinees have strong motivation and opportunity to learn countermeasures. The development of comprehensive countermeasure resistance strategies—including improved test designs, better question formulation, and alternative assessment methods—represents a more promising direction than relying solely on detection of countermeasure attempts. The field would benefit from greater transparency about these vulnerabilities rather than maintaining public claims that overstate detection capabilities.
The analysis above is original editorial content based on our review of this research. For the complete study including full data, methodology details, and author discussion, access the original publication below.
Related research
Other studies in this category that may be of interest.
The effects of mental countermeasures on psychophysiological memory detection: Facilitating orientation is…
[002] (2022)The effect of mental countermeasures on a novel brain‐based feedback concealed information…
[003] (2019)Frequent Countermeasure Usage by Narcissistic Examinees in the Concealed Information Test
[004] (2018)James Q. Murdoch: How to Pass a Polygraph, San Bernardino 2018, 23…
[005] (2018)The effect of countermeasures against the reaction time based concealed information test…
[006] (2016)Influence of countermeasures on the validity of the Concealed Information Test
Join Our Examiner Network
APA-trained examiners using validated techniques can apply to join the LieDetectorTest.com network.
Keep reading the ledger.
Every peer-reviewed study on polygraph and deception detection we track — catalogued, searchable and citable.

