29 Examiners Available Now — Contact Them DirectlyNo Booking Fee — You Pay Your Examiner Directly270+ Testing Locations Across the U.S., Canada & UKFree Polygraph Research Database — 44,000+ StudiesWe Promote Clear Standards & Best Practice in Private Polygraph TestingLearning Center — Independent Guides to Every Type of Polygraph TestSame-Day Verbal Result · Written Report Within 48 HoursVetted Examiners Trained at Accredited Polygraph Schools100% Confidential — Private, Appointment-Only TestingPolygraph Glossary (600+ Terms), Book Library & School DirectoryTrusted by 10,000+ Clients, Attorneys & Organizations
LieDetectorTest.com Stop guessing. Get the truth.
Research ledger
Countermeasures and CQT Accuracy

Home › Polygraph Research › Countermeasures and CQT Accuracy

Catalogue entry · Countermeasures Research

Countermeasures and CQT Accuracy

Charles Robert Honts; David C. Raskin; John C. Kircher — Journal of Applied Psychology,

1994Published
Experimental participants in countermeasure conditionsSample size
Key findings

Definitive study on countermeasures in CQT. Found that trained countermeasure users could reduce detection rates, but detection of countermeasure use itself is possible. Untrained subjects remained highly detectable.

Abstract

Landmark countermeasure study finding trained countermeasure users could affect CQT accuracy, but untrained subjects remained highly detectable.

Methodology

Controlled experiment training subjects in mental and physical countermeasures versus untrained controls.

Detailed summary

Honts, Raskin, and Kircher's landmark study found that while trained countermeasure users could reduce CQT detection rates, untrained subjects remained highly detectable. This important distinction suggests that while countermeasures are a theoretical vulnerability, the practical threat is limited to individuals who receive specific training.

Implications for polygraph practice

The trained/untrained distinction helps calibrate the realistic countermeasure threat: significant for motivated, prepared examinees but minimal for the vast majority of test subjects.

Comprehensive study analysis

An in-depth, original analysis of this research study's methodology, findings, and significance for the polygraph profession.

Background & Context

The 1994 Honts, Raskin, and Kircher study emerged at a critical juncture in polygraph science, when countermeasures—deliberate techniques used to distort physiological responses—were becoming an increasingly recognized threat to test validity. Prior to this landmark research, the polygraph field possessed limited empirical data on how effectively informed examinees could manipulate Control Question Test (CQT) outcomes through simple physical or mental techniques.

The study's significance was amplified by its real-world context. Between 1986 and 1990, polygraph use for national security screening in the U.S. Department of Defense rose 586%, with vital decisions about access to cryptology, government secrets, and nuclear command and control being largely based on polygraph test results. This expansion made understanding countermeasure vulnerabilities not just a scientific question but a matter of national security. Previous research had demonstrated that physical countermeasures could affect test outcomes, but no comprehensive study had systematically compared both physical and mental techniques under realistic field conditions with proper controls.

Research Design & Methodology

The experiment recruited 120 subjects from the general community who were given polygraph tests by an examiner using field techniques. Twenty subjects were innocent, and of the 100 guilty subjects, 80 were trained in the use of either a physical countermeasure (biting the tongue or pressing the toes to the floor) or a mental countermeasure (counting backward by 7) to be applied while control questions were being presented during their examinations. This created a rigorous experimental design with multiple conditions: innocent controls, guilty controls (untrained), guilty with physical countermeasures, and guilty with mental countermeasures.

The methodology emphasized ecological validity by employing authentic field procedures. Subjects were screened to exclude those with cardiovascular disease, mental health conditions, or prior polygraph experience. The countermeasure training was brief—requiring only about 30 minutes of instruction—to simulate realistic scenarios where examinees might obtain countermeasure information from readily available sources. Importantly, the polygraph examiner remained blind to subject guilt status and countermeasure training, eliminating potential experimenter bias.

Physiological measures included multiple channels tracking cardiovascular activity, skin conductance (electrodermal), and respiratory patterns. Examiner decisions were coded as 1 for truthful, 2 for inconclusive, and 3 for deceptive, creating an ordinal scale based on the underlying interval scale for numerical scoring. Both traditional examiner decisions and numerical scoring methods were analyzed, along with exploratory discriminant function analysis to assess whether countermeasure use could be detected from physiological patterns.

Results & Key Findings

The mental and physical countermeasures were equally effective: Each enabled approximately 50% of subjects to defeat the polygraph test, with the strongest countermeasure effects observed in the cardiovascular measures. This finding represented a dramatic reduction in detection accuracy compared to control conditions, demonstrating that simple, trainable techniques could significantly compromise CQT validity.

The untrained guilty subjects showed markedly different outcomes than their countermeasure-trained counterparts, supporting the study's critical distinction between informed and naive examinees. The main effect of correct use of countermeasures was significant (F(1,77) = 10.47, p < .01), with subjects who reported correct use of countermeasures producing a mean numerical score of 3.30, shifting their profiles toward the truthful range.

Key statistical findings included:

  • 50% defeat rate for both physical and mental countermeasure groups among trained guilty subjects
  • Skin conductance responses were relatively unaffected by countermeasures manipulation, but a different picture emerged for cardiovascular measures
  • Countermeasures were difficult to detect either instrumentally or through observation
  • A discriminant function correctly classified 75.8% of subjects and improved classification by over 20% compared to traditional examiner evaluations, suggesting potential for algorithmic countermeasure detection

The equivalence between physical techniques (tongue biting, toe pressing) and mental techniques (counting backward by 7) was particularly noteworthy, demonstrating that countermeasures need not involve detectable movements to be effective.

Discussion & Significance

This study fundamentally recalibrated the polygraph field's understanding of countermeasure threats. The critical finding was not simply that countermeasures work, but that they require specific training to be effective. The distinction between trained countermeasure users (50% defeat rate) and untrained guilty subjects (who remained highly detectable) suggested that the practical threat was limited to motivated, informed examinees rather than representing a universal vulnerability.

The research demonstrated that the strongest countermeasure effects were observed in cardiovascular measures, and countermeasures were difficult to detect either instrumentally or through observation. This finding challenged examiner confidence in behavioral observation as a countermeasure detection method. However, the discriminant analysis results offered hope that computerized detection algorithms might identify countermeasure patterns that human examiners miss, pointing toward technological solutions.

The study's implications extended beyond the laboratory. With polygraph use expanding rapidly in national security contexts, the finding that brief, accessible training could enable half of guilty individuals to produce false negative outcomes raised serious questions about screening program effectiveness. Yet the untrained/trained distinction also suggested that widespread dissemination of countermeasure information—rather than the techniques themselves—posed the primary threat to test validity.

Limitations & Considerations

As with all laboratory research, the study's ecological validity faced inherent constraints despite efforts to employ field procedures. Mock crime scenarios with recruited volunteers differ fundamentally from real-world criminal investigations or security screenings in terms of psychological stakes, stress levels, and consequences. The 30-minute countermeasure training may represent either a best-case scenario (highly effective instruction) or worst-case scenario (unrealistically comprehensive preparation) compared to how real examinees might learn countermeasure techniques.

Additional limitations include:

  • The single-examiner design prevented assessment of inter-examiner reliability in detecting countermeasures
  • Subject self-reports of correct countermeasure application relied on subjective assessment rather than objective verification
  • The study focused exclusively on CQT format, limiting generalizability to other polygraph techniques
  • The laboratory research establishing these findings is likely to represent worst-case scenarios, and the problem of effective countermeasures seems to be substantially ameliorated by the use of computer-based statistical analysis

Practical Applications

For polygraph examiners, this research underscores the importance of integrating countermeasure awareness into test protocols without becoming paralyzed by the threat. The findings suggest that while trained countermeasures pose a genuine challenge, the majority of examinees lacking specific instruction remain detectable. Examiners should be cautious about over-relying on behavioral observation for countermeasure detection, as the study demonstrated that both physical and mental techniques can evade observational detection. The discriminant analysis results point toward computerized scoring algorithms as potentially superior tools for identifying aberrant physiological patterns indicative of countermeasure use.

For consumers and policymakers, the study provides essential context for evaluating polygraph evidence. In criminal investigations where examinees have limited access to countermeasure information, CQT validity may remain reasonably robust. However, in screening contexts—particularly national security applications where examinees may be sophisticated and motivated to research countermeasures—the 50% defeat rate among trained individuals represents a substantial vulnerability. The research supports the position that polygraph results should never serve as the sole basis for consequential decisions, particularly when examinees have both motive and opportunity to research countermeasure techniques prior to testing.

Read the original study

The analysis above is original editorial content based on our review of this research. For the complete study including full data, methodology details, and author discussion, access the original publication below.

Related research

Other studies in this category that may be of interest.

Join Our Examiner Network

APA-trained examiners using validated techniques can apply to join the LieDetectorTest.com network.

Apply now →

Keep reading the ledger.

Every peer-reviewed study on polygraph and deception detection we track — catalogued, searchable and citable.

Need to book now? Our online booking system is open 24/7. Speak directly with our team about your test or booking.