Home › Polygraph Research › The detection of physical countermeasures
Catalogue entry · Countermeasures Research
The detection of physical countermeasures
Honts, C. R., Hodes, R. L. — Polygraph,
Polygraph examiners detected only 12% of participants using physical countermeasures, with trained countermeasures proving difficult to detect through either physiological chart analysis or behavioral observation.
Abstract
This 1983 study by Honts and Hodes examined whether polygraph examiners could detect when examinees employed physical countermeasures during testing. Using laboratory experiments with comparison question tests, the researchers found that examiners detected only 12% of physical countermeasure users, demonstrating that simple techniques like tongue biting or muscle tensing were difficult to identify through chart analysis or behavioral observation.
Methodology
Laboratory experiment using mock crime paradigm with comparison question test format, examining examiner ability to detect physical countermeasures through blind chart evaluation and behavioral observation under field-standard testing conditions.
Detailed summary
This landmark 1983 study addressed a critical gap in polygraph research by empirically examining whether examiners could detect physical countermeasures during comparison question testing. Using a controlled laboratory design, participants were trained in simple physical maneuvers designed to augment physiological responses during control questions, while polygraph examiners blindly evaluated charts and observed behavior. The results were sobering for the polygraph profession: examiners detected only 12% of countermeasure users, and the physiological data revealed no consistent detectable patterns. The minimal observable behavioral cues meant these techniques could be applied covertly. This foundational work demonstrated that polygraph testing possessed a significant vulnerability to deliberate defeat strategies and prompted subsequent research into counter-countermeasures and examiner training protocols.
Implications for polygraph practice
This study revealed a fundamental weakness in polygraph's operational reliability and forced the polygraph profession to acknowledge that examiners could not reliably detect trained countermeasures. The findings have significant implications for national security screening programs and criminal investigations, highlighting the need for improved detection methods, examiner training, and protocol development to address countermeasure vulnerabilities.
Comprehensive study analysis
An in-depth, original analysis of this research study's methodology, findings, and significance for the polygraph profession.
Background & Context
The 1983 study by Charles R. Honts and Robert L. Hodes represents a landmark investigation in polygraph countermeasures research, addressing one of the most critical vulnerabilities in lie detection technology. Published in the journal *Polygraph*, this study emerged at a pivotal time when concerns about countermeasure effectiveness were beginning to challenge confidence in polygraph testing, particularly for national security screening applications.
Prior to this research, the polygraph profession had limited empirical data on whether examiners could identify when examinees employed deliberate strategies to defeat the test. The work by Honts and colleagues demonstrated that polygraph examiners do a poor job in detecting countermeasures, fundamentally challenging assumptions about examiner vigilance and instrumental detection capabilities. This study laid the groundwork for an entire line of research at the University of Utah that would shape federal countermeasure protocols.
The researchers (Honts, Raskin, Kircher, and Barland) primarily responsible for our current understanding of countermeasures were employed at the University of Utah, and since 1983, subject matter experts within the polygraph community collaborated to develop countermeasure procedures. The timing was critical as polygraph use in government security screening was expanding rapidly.
Research Design & Methodology
The study employed a controlled laboratory experiment examining whether physical countermeasures could be detected through physiological chart analysis or behavioral observation by polygraph examiners. The research used a mock crime paradigm with comparison question test (CQT) format, the most widely used polygraph technique in criminal and security screening contexts.
Key methodological elements included:
- Physical countermeasure strategies: Participants were trained in simple physical maneuvers such as tongue biting or muscle tensing designed to augment physiological responses during control questions
- Blind evaluation protocol: Examiners assessed charts without knowledge of which participants had been trained in countermeasures
- Multiple detection criteria: Researchers examined both instrumental indicators in the physiological data and behavioral observations by examiners
- Realistic test conditions: Field-standard polygraph procedures and equipment were employed to maximize ecological validity
The study specifically focused on whether these countermeasures left detectable "signatures" in the physiological recordings or whether trained observers could identify suspicious behavior during testing. This was a critical practical question for operational polygraph programs.
Results & Key Findings
The original examiner detected only 12% of the physical countermeasure users, and trained countermeasures are difficult to detect. This finding represented a sobering reality check for the polygraph profession.
Additional findings included:
- Low detection rates: Examiners failed to identify the vast majority of participants employing physical countermeasures, suggesting these techniques could be applied covertly
- No reliable chart indicators: The physiological data did not reveal consistent patterns that could be used to flag countermeasure use
- Behavioral cues were minimal: Simple physical countermeasures like toe-pressing produced no observable behavioral indicators
- Effectiveness varied by technique: Different types of physical countermeasures showed varying degrees of detectability
There are a number of ways of inducing mild pain when responding to comparison questions (e.g., biting one's tongue, stepping on a hidden tack in one's shoe), and the heightened physiological responses that accompany pain can mimic the responses polygraph examiners take as indicators of deception. This mechanism made physical countermeasures particularly insidious—they exploited the same physiological channels the test relied upon.
Muscle contraction might produce similar reactions and might be difficult to detect, depending on the amount of training and the muscle groups involved, suggesting that countermeasures targeting non-visible muscle groups would be especially problematic.
Discussion & Significance
The implications of this research were profound for polygraph practice and policy. Later work by Honts and his colleagues suggests that polygraph examiners do a poor job in detecting countermeasures, a conclusion that reverberated through subsequent studies and policy debates. The findings challenged the widely held belief that trained examiners could spot deceptive behaviors and chart anomalies.
This study became foundational evidence in the 2003 National Research Council's comprehensive review of polygraph testing. There is evidence that some countermeasures used by innocent examinees can in fact increase their chances of appearing deceptive, highlighting an additional concern: countermeasures posed risks not only from guilty individuals but also from anxious innocent persons attempting to "help" themselves pass.
The research influenced federal policy development. During the mid-1990s polygraph countermeasures within the Federal Government were initially defined, taught and oversight provided at the Department of Defense Polygraph Institute (DoDPI, now named the National Center for Credibility Assessment), and NCCA personnel compiled existing research and developed countermeasure protocols that are currently employed by the Federal Government. The Honts and Hodes work provided empirical grounding for these protocols.
Limitations & Considerations
Several important limitations to the research on countermeasures are worth noting. First, all of the studies have involved mock crimes and most use experimenters or research assistants as polygraph examiners. The laboratory setting, while allowing experimental control, may not fully capture the dynamics of high-stakes field examinations where motivation and consequences differ substantially.
Additional limitations include:
- The study examined relatively simple physical countermeasures that required minimal training—more sophisticated techniques may have different detectability profiles
- Sample sizes in early countermeasure research were typically modest, limiting statistical power for detecting subtle effects
- Examiner experience levels and training in countermeasure detection may have varied
- The research focused on detection rather than prevention, leaving open questions about pre-test warnings and other deterrence strategies
Practical Applications
For polygraph examiners, this research underscored the critical need for enhanced countermeasure awareness and detection training. There have been reports of the use of mechanisms to detect countermeasure in polygraph tests, notably, reports of use of motion sensors in some polygraph equipment to detect muscle tensing, representing technological responses to the detection challenge. However, these sorts of detectors can be effective in detecting specific types of countermeasures, but their general validity and utility remain a matter for conjecture.
For consumers and policymakers, the findings raise important questions about the reliability of polygraph results, particularly in security screening contexts where examinees may have advance knowledge of the process. The low detection rates suggest that negative findings (failing to detect deception) may be particularly unreliable when countermeasures are possible. These concerns remain relevant today in evaluating polygraph evidence in legal, employment, and national security contexts.
The analysis above is original editorial content based on our review of this research. For the complete study including full data, methodology details, and author discussion, access the original publication below.
Related research
Other studies in this category that may be of interest.
The effects of mental countermeasures on psychophysiological memory detection: Facilitating orientation is…
[002] (2022)The effect of mental countermeasures on a novel brain‐based feedback concealed information…
[003] (2019)Frequent Countermeasure Usage by Narcissistic Examinees in the Concealed Information Test
[004] (2018)James Q. Murdoch: How to Pass a Polygraph, San Bernardino 2018, 23…
[005] (2018)The effect of countermeasures against the reaction time based concealed information test…
[006] (2016)Influence of countermeasures on the validity of the Concealed Information Test
Join Our Examiner Network
APA-trained examiners using validated techniques can apply to join the LieDetectorTest.com network.
Keep reading the ledger.
Every peer-reviewed study on polygraph and deception detection we track — catalogued, searchable and citable.

