29 Examiners Available Now — Contact Them DirectlyNo Booking Fee — You Pay Your Examiner Directly270+ Testing Locations Across the U.S., Canada & UKFree Polygraph Research Database — 44,000+ StudiesWe Promote Clear Standards & Best Practice in Private Polygraph TestingLearning Center — Independent Guides to Every Type of Polygraph TestSame-Day Verbal Result · Written Report Within 48 HoursVetted Examiners Trained at Accredited Polygraph Schools100% Confidential — Private, Appointment-Only TestingPolygraph Glossary (600+ Terms), Book Library & School DirectoryTrusted by 10,000+ Clients, Attorneys & Organizations
LieDetectorTest.com Stop guessing. Get the truth.
Research ledger
Prison Mental Health Screening tools: choices and sensitivity

Home › Polygraph Research › Prison Mental Health Screening tools: choices and sensitivity

Catalogue entry · Screening & Personnel Security

Prison Mental Health Screening tools: choices and sensitivity

David Dietzel — Assessment and Development Matters,

2017Published
74 male prisonersSample size
Key findings

The three validated screening tools produced referral rates ranging from 47.3% to 100% in the same sample, a spread of over 50 percentage points, demonstrating that prison mental health screening tools should never be treated as interchangeable.

Abstract

This 2017 study by Dietzel, Synnott, and Ioannou examines the comparative sensitivity of three validated prison mental health screening tools — the BJMHS, CMHS-M, and EMHS — administered concurrently alongside the GHQ-12 to a sample of 74 male Irish prisoners. The study reveals dramatic divergence in referral rates across the four instruments, from 47.3% (EMHS) to 100% (BJMHS), demonstrating that validated tools are not interchangeable and that tool selection carries significant clinical and operational consequences in correctional settings.

Methodology

Three prison mental health screening tools (BJMHS, CMHS-M, EMHS) were administered concurrently with the GHQ-12 as a reference measure to 74 adult male prisoners in Ireland, with referral rates compared across all four instruments using each tool's published scoring criteria.

Detailed summary

This study addressed the critical need for effective mental health screening in prisons by comparing three validated instruments designed for non-specialist administration. The research used simple yes-no format tools (BJMHS, CMHS-M, EMHS) with the GHQ-12 as a reference benchmark in a sample of 74 male Irish prisoners. Results revealed striking disparities in referral rates despite all tools having prior validation support, with rates ranging from 47.3% to 100%. The GHQ-12 reference indicated 79.7% of the sample exhibited mental health problems, highlighting significant inconsistencies in screening tool performance.

Implications for polygraph practice

The findings raise serious concerns about the reliability and practical utility of current prison mental health screening tools, suggesting need for improved standardization and validation in correctional settings before widespread implementation.

Comprehensive study analysis

An in-depth, original analysis of this research study's methodology, findings, and significance for the polygraph profession.

Background & Context

Mental illness within correctional settings represents one of the most pressing — and chronically under-resourced — challenges in modern criminal justice. According to a 2017 Prison Reform Trust report, mental illness in prisons is worsening, with 49% of women and 23% of men in UK prisons suffering from both anxiety and depression, compared to a general population rate of just 15%; meanwhile, 25% of female and 15% of male prisoners exhibit symptoms indicative of psychosis, versus a general population rate of only 4%.

The crisis extends to self-harm and suicide: self-harm incidents in UK prisons reached a record high of 40,161 (up 7,848 from 2015), and the suicide rate doubled between 2013 and 2016, with 113 deaths recorded in 2016 alone. These stark figures underscore the urgent need for effective, scalable early-detection systems within custodial environments.

The fundamental bottleneck is one of capacity and expertise. Most prison systems cannot sustain large-scale, in-depth psychological evaluations requiring extensive clinician time and specialist training. A landmark 2013 systematic review by Martin et al. compared the sensitivity and specificity of 22 mental health screening tools across 24 studies conducted in adult jails and prisons, ultimately identifying several tools as promising and warranting further examination — setting the stage for the comparative empirical work that Dietzel and colleagues undertook.

Research Design & Methodology

The study aimed to compare three validated prison mental health screening instruments — the Brief Jail Mental Health Screen (BJMHS), the Correctional Mental Health Screen for Men (CMHS-M), and the England Mental Health Screen (EMHS) — all of which use simple yes-no question formats designed for administration by non-specialist staff, administered alongside the GHQ-12 as a reference measure to a sample of 74 male Irish prisoners.

Key design elements of the study include:

  • Sample: 74 adult male prisoners in an Irish correctional facility
  • Instruments compared: BJMHS (8 items), CMHS-M (12 items, one item removed), EMHS (4 items with follow-ups), and GHQ-12 as a reference benchmark
  • Format: All three primary screening tools used yes-no response formats, scored by affirmative response counts
  • Exclusion rationale: The Jail Screening Assessment Tool (JSAT) was excluded due to its structured interview format, making it incomparable on the same basis
  • Reference standard: The GHQ-12 served as the sensitivity reference point, not a gold-standard clinical diagnosis

The GHQ-12 (General Health Questionnaire, 12-item version) was selected as the comparative benchmark because of its extensive validation history in diverse settings, including forensic and prison contexts. Each of the three primary screening tools was scored according to its own published cut-off thresholds, and secondary analyses were conducted for the BJMHS and CMHS-M to explore the effect of modified scoring criteria.

Results & Key Findings

The headline finding: all three validated screening tools produced dramatically divergent referral rates when applied to the identical sample of 74 prisoners — ranging from 47.3% to 100% — despite all having received prior independent validation support. The GHQ-12 reference measure indicated that 79.7% of the sample exhibited some mental health problem using standard 5/6 scoring.

Tool-by-tool results were as follows:

  • BJMHS: Flagged 100% of inmates for further evaluation under standard scoring. Even modified analyses — examining only symptom questions (1–6) or only history questions (7–8) separately — still flagged 98.6% and 97.3% respectively, indicating the BJMHS was markedly more sensitive than the GHQ-12 reference.
  • CMHS-M: Flagged 60.8% of inmates at the standard cut-off of 6/11 (one item removed). Lowering the cut-off to 4/5 increased this to 71.6%, still notably below the GHQ-12 reference rate of 79.7%.
  • EMHS: The most conservative tool, flagging only 47.3% of inmates — more than 30 percentage points below the GHQ-12 reference rate. Unlike the other tools, the EMHS focuses primarily on historical psychiatric information rather than current symptom presentation.
  • GHQ-12 (reference): Indicated 79.7% prevalence of mental health problems using 5/6 scoring, serving as the mid-range comparative anchor.

The BJMHS over-flagged relative to the GHQ-12 by roughly 20 percentage points, the CMHS-M under-flagged by approximately 20 percentage points, and the EMHS under-flagged by more than 30 percentage points. Crucially, comparison with prior studies revealed that these patterns are not universal — earlier research with much larger samples found the EMHS to actually outperform the BJMHS in sensitivity in some settings.

Discussion & Significance

The central contribution of this study is a clear empirical demonstration that validated, widely-used prison mental health screening tools are not interchangeable. A prison selecting the EMHS over the BJMHS on practical grounds — given the EMHS's simpler, historically-oriented structure — could be systematically under-identifying inmates in acute psychological distress. Conversely, a tool that refers nearly every prisoner for evaluation may overwhelm the very specialist resources it is designed to protect.

The structural differences between tools help explain the divergence. The EMHS focuses on prior psychiatric contact, past medication, and historical self-harm, whereas the BJMHS probes current symptom experience including active psychotic ideation. In a population where psychiatric histories may be underdocumented but current distress is high — as is commonly the case in remand and reception populations — retrospective tools will systematically miss acutely at-risk individuals.

This study also advances a methodological argument with broad implications for correctional psychology research: validation studies conducted in isolation, testing a single tool against a diagnostic standard within a single population, may not predict how that same tool will perform relative to its peers in a different setting. The authors argue persuasively that future research should prioritize head-to-head comparative validation rather than siloed instrument-by-instrument evaluation, an approach that would better serve practitioners making real-world tool-selection decisions.

Limitations & Considerations

The authors candidly acknowledge several important constraints that must temper interpretation of the findings:

  • Small sample size: At n = 74, the sample is substantially smaller than those used in prior validation studies for these same tools, limiting statistical power and generalizability.
  • No gold-standard diagnosis: The GHQ-12, used as the reference point, is itself a screening instrument rather than a clinical diagnostic assessment. It can only approximate true mental illness prevalence in the sample, making it impossible to determine which tool had the highest specificity against an authoritative benchmark.
  • Single-gender, single-setting sample: The sample consisted exclusively of male prisoners from a single Irish facility, meaning the results may not transfer to female populations, other national contexts, or remand versus sentenced populations.
  • Modified CMHS-M scoring: One item was removed from the CMHS-M due to perceived unsuitability to the sample, introducing a non-standard administration condition that limits direct comparison with published norms.
  • Cross-study sensitivity variability: The authors note that prior large-scale studies (e.g., Cagnon, 2009, n=1,339; Evans et al., 2010, n=530) produced markedly different sensitivity rankings for the same tools, underlining the context-dependence of these instruments.

These limitations do not undermine the study's core finding — that substantial sensitivity divergence exists between tools — but they do appropriately constrain conclusions about which tool is definitively "best" for any given context.

Practical Applications

For correctional administrators, mental health coordinators, and forensic practitioners, this research delivers a clear operational message: the choice of screening tool is not a neutral administrative decision. Selecting a tool with low sensitivity in a given population will result in a substantial proportion of mentally unwell inmates going undetected and untreated during a period — prison reception — when intervention may be most impactful. Practitioners should be aware that a tool validated in one correctional setting or population may not perform equivalently in their specific context.

The study also reinforces the value of brief, non-specialist-administered psychometric tools as a pragmatic first step in custodial mental health pathways, while cautioning that no single tool should be treated as a definitive triage instrument. Where resources allow, facilities would benefit from conducting local calibration exercises — comparing tool outputs to clinical assessments within their own populations — before committing to a single screening instrument as standard practice. The follow-up 2022 update by Dietzel, Kewley, McIlroy, and Synnott further suggests that this line of research remains active and policy-relevant.

Read the original study

The analysis above is original editorial content based on our review of this research. For the complete study including full data, methodology details, and author discussion, access the original publication below.

Related research

Other studies in this category that may be of interest.

Join Our Examiner Network

APA-trained examiners using validated techniques can apply to join the LieDetectorTest.com network.

Apply now →

Keep reading the ledger.

Every peer-reviewed study on polygraph and deception detection we track — catalogued, searchable and citable.

Need to book now? Our online booking system is open 24/7. Speak directly with our team about your test or booking.