Home › Polygraph Research › Researchers › Gershon Ben-Shakhar
Researcher file
Gershon Ben-Shakhar
Psychophysiological detection of concealed information and critique of traditional polygraph methods
Researcher record
About Gershon Ben-Shakhar
Gershon Ben-Shakhar is a Professor Emeritus of Psychology at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, where he taught in the Department of Psychology from 1981 on, ultimately as a Professor and for a time as the Chair of the Department and the Dean of the Faculty of Social Sciences. He earned his B.A. in Psychology and Statistics (1966), an M.A. in Psychology (1970), and a Ph.D. in Psychology (1975) from The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and was a Post-Doctoral Fellow at Northwestern University in Evanston, Illinois, from 1975 to 1976. He also served in several administrative roles including President of the Open University of Israel (2003-2008).
Ben-Shakhar's research fundamentally shaped the scientific understanding of polygraph testing and deception detection. His work focused on cognitive psychophysiology, particularly the role of stimulus novelty and significance in orienting response elicitation and its habituation process and on psychophysiological detection of deception and concealed information. His studies led him to the conclusion that the prevailing method of polygraph ("Lie Detection") tests is flawed and has no scientific validity. He championed the Concealed Information Test (CIT), also known as the Guilty Knowledge Test (GKT), as a scientifically sound alternative to the traditional Comparison Question Test (CQT). His influential meta-analyses, including landmark studies in 2001, 2003, and 2014, established the empirical foundation for the CIT's validity using physiological measures such as skin conductance, respiration, heart rate, and P300 brain responses. His efforts in this direction influenced the decision that polygraph tests would not serve as admissible evidence in Israeli criminal courts.
Ben-Shakhar is among the most cited researchers in deception detection science and has been recognized with Israel's highest honors. He received the prestigious EMET Prize in 2011 for his scientific and applied contributions in Psychology, and received the Israel Prize in 2024. He has published more than 100 articles and book chapters, with his 1990 book "Theories and Applications in the Detection of Deception" (co-authored with John J. Furedy) becoming a foundational text in the field. He has collaborated extensively with leading researchers including Eitan Elaad, Bruno Verschuere, Ewout H. Meijer, and William G. Iacono, producing influential work on countermeasures, field validity, and the theoretical mechanisms underlying psychophysiological detection.
Beyond polygraph research, Ben-Shakhar's scholarly contributions span psychological testing, individual differences in cognitive ability and human judgment and decision making. Early in his career, he created a testing unit at the Social Sciences Faculty of Hebrew University to design an aptitude tests battery, which was soon adopted by all faculties and eventually formed the foundation for the unified psychometric test adopted by all universities in Israel. His research on confirmation bias in expert judgment, graphology validity, and orienting responses has influenced broader understanding of cognitive processes, demonstrating how basic psychophysiology research can inform real-world applications in forensic psychology, personnel selection, and legal policy.
Research methodology profile
Research areas
Co-author network
Researchers who have co-authored studies with Gershon Ben-Shakhar.
Publications [59]
All peer-reviewed studies by Gershon Ben-Shakhar in our database.
The promise of eye-tracking in the detection of concealed memories
Eye-tracking methods demonstrate particular promise for countermeasure resistance, with task-dependent gaze patterns and multiple oculomotor indices showing differential responses to familiar versus unfamiliar items. [002] 2023 Journal of Applied Research in Memory and CognitionThe effects of mental countermeasures on psychophysiological memory detection: Facilitating orientation is easy, stopping inhibition is not
Facilitating orientation proved easy but stopping inhibition proved impossible - skin conductance was successfully manipulated while respiration and heart rate remained resistant to voluntary control. [003] 2022 PsychophysiologyCountering information leakage in the Concealed Information Test: The effects of item detailedness
The study tested whether item detailedness could counter information leakage effects in the CIT, investigating if more specific questions preserve detection accuracy while reducing false positives from contaminated innocents. [004] 2021 Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender ProfilingFallacies in the estimation of the validity of the Comparison Question Polygraph Test: A reply to Ginton (2020)
The authors dismiss Ginton's defenses and conclude his paired-examination validity estimates are untrustworthy due to confirmation bias, criterion contamination, and violated methodological assumptions that inflate apparent accuracy. [005] 2020The Picture Superiority Effect in Memory Detection: Modality Effects in the Concealed Information Test
Pictorially encoded crime details were easier to detect than verbally encoded details. Items encoded and tested in the same modality showed better detection. Verbally encoded items could not be detected… [006] 2019 Law and Human BehaviorCurrent Status of Forensic Lie Detection with the Comparison Question Technique: An Update
Updated review of CQT research, reaffirming conclusions from the NRC (2003). Argued for caution in interpreting CQT accuracy claims, noting potential overestimation in experimental studies. Stimulated significant debate and further… [007] 2019 Cognitive Research: Principles and ImplicationsDetecting concealed familiarity using eye movements: the role of task demands
In the concealed condition, participants showed significantly more fixations toward familiar faces (d = 1.06), but this effect completely disappeared when countermeasures were employed (d = 0.17), unlike memory-based tasks… [008] 2019 Legal and Criminological PsychologyThe case against the use of polygraph examinations to monitor post-conviction sex offenders
The CQT has no scientific basis for use with sex offenders and suffers from major theoretical and methodological flaws that make it even more problematic in correctional settings than in… [009] 2018 Detecting Concealed Information and DeceptionThe External Validity of Studies Examining the Detection of Concealed Knowledge Using the Concealed Information Test
[010] 2018 Journal of Applied Research in Memory and CognitionDo You Know Him? Gaze Dynamics Toward Familiar Faces on a Concealed Information Test
The study achieved 89% accuracy in detecting concealed face recognition using eye-tracking. Participants showed an orientation-avoidance pattern (initial fixation on familiar faces followed by avoidance) that persisted even under countermeasure… [011] 2018 Law and Human BehaviorCurrent status of forensic lie detection with the comparison question technique: An update of the 2003 National Academy of Sciences report on polygraph testing
Research quality has not improved in the 15 years since the NAS report, and fundamental problems with CQT validation—weak theoretical foundations, poor study quality, and unknown error rates—remain unresolved. [012] 2016 PsychophysiologyDeception detection with behavioral, autonomic, and neural measures: conceptual and methodological considerations that warrant modesty
The review identified significant conceptual clarity issues and methodological problems across deception detection paradigms, particularly challenging the oversold promises of neuroimaging-based lie detection technologies. [013] 2013 Cognitive NeurodynamicsA comment on Farwell (2012): brain fingerprinting: a comprehensive tutorial review of detection of concealed information with event-related brain potentials
Of the studies cited by Farwell to support brain fingerprinting's perfect accuracy, only one peer-reviewed laboratory study with 20 participants and two small field studies (4 and 6 participants) met… [014] 2012 • SYSTEMATIC REVIEW Frontiers JournalsCurrent Research and Potential Applications of the Concealed Information Test: An Overview
Comprehensive overview of CIT research highlighting its strong theoretical foundation in orienting response theory. Noted that CIT's false positive rate remains extremely low (~5%) across studies, making it valuable for… [015] 2012 Journal of Experimental Psychology: AppliedAlgorithms for detecting concealed knowledge among groups when the critical information is unavailable
Reanalysis of three datasets showed that both averaging and PCA-based algorithms successfully detected critical items and differentiated knowledgeable from unknowledgeable subjects with efficiency approaching standard CIT, provided at least 2-5… [016] 2012 Memory and LawDetection of Concealed Stored Memories with Psychophysiological and Neuroimaging Methods
[017] 2011 Memory DetectionThe Concealed Information Test in the courtroom: legal aspects
[018] 2011 Memory DetectionCountermeasures
[019] 2011 Memory Detection: Theory and Application of the Concealed Information TestThe CIT in the courtroom: Legal aspects
[020] 2011 • REVIEW BookMemory Detection: Theory and Application of the Concealed Information Test (Book)
Comprehensive edited volume with contributions from leading CIT researchers worldwide. Covered theoretical foundations, laboratory research, field applications in Japan, countermeasures, and legal issues. [021] 2011 Memory Detection: Theory and Application of the Concealed Information TestPractical guidelines for developing a CIT
Central crime details directly related to crime execution are recalled at 90.2% compared to only 65.9% for peripheral details. Guidelines emphasize selecting information present in perpetrator memory but unknown to… [022] 2010 • EXPERIMENTAL PsychophysiologyPsychophysiological and Behavioral Measures for Detecting Concealed Information: The Role of Memory for Crime Details
Examined how memory strength affects CIT detection accuracy. Found that central crime details produced stronger physiological responses than peripheral details, with implications for real-world CIT application. [023] 2009 Applied Psychophysiology and BiofeedbackCountering Countermeasures in the Concealed Information Test Using Covert Respiration Measures
[024] 2008 Biological PsychologyCovert respiration measures for the detection of concealed information
[025] 2006 International Journal of PsychophysiologyFinger pulse waveform length in the detection of concealed information
FPWL achieved detection accuracy comparable to established measures (SCR .70–.84, RLL .73–.82), with improved performance when measures were combined. FPWL showed potential resistance to habituation effects that degraded SCR and… [026] 2005 Journal of Applied PsychologyBehavioral and physiological measures in the detection of concealed information
Skin conductance response (SCR) reliably detected concealed information across both paradigms, but reaction time (RT) differentiated relevant from neutral items only when the critical words denoted personally significant information (own… [027] 2003 Journal of Experimental Psychology: AppliedEstimating the validity of the guilty knowledge test from simulated experiments: The external validity of mock crime studies
Realistic mock crime procedures produced lower recall rates and weaker GKT detection efficiency compared to standard procedures where participants were told crime details in advance. Effects were mediated by question… [028] 2003 Journal of Applied PsychologyCIT and Countermeasures
Found that compared with CQT, there is less evidence that individuals tested through CIT could employ countermeasures to alter results. CIT demonstrated greater resistance to deliberate manipulation. [029] 2003Concealed knowledge tests employed in field practice
Overall effect size was d = 1.55, with mock-crime studies producing d = 2.09. Under optimal conditions (mock crime, motivation, deceptive responses, ≥5 questions), effect size reached d = 3.12,… [030] 2002 Journal of Applied PsychologyEffects of questions' repetition and variation on the efficiency of the guilty knowledge test: A reexamination
Electrodermal detection efficiency showed a dramatic monotonic increase with question diversity, achieving ROC areas of 0.68, 0.81, and 0.99 for conditions with 1, 4, and 12 different questions respectively, demonstrating… [031] 2002A critical review of the control questions test (CQT)
The CQT was found to lack adequate scientific validation, failing to satisfy major Daubert criteria. Key problems included absence of proper theoretical foundation, inadequate control conditions, high false positive rates,… [032] 2000 PsychophysiologyOrienting Response Reinstatement and Dishabituation: The Effects of Substituting, Adding and Deleting Components of Nonsignificant Stimuli
Component substitution systematically affected OR reinstatement, with between-category substitutions producing larger responses than within-category changes. Adding and deleting components had equivalent effects, supporting the theory that feature mismatch rather than… [033] 1999 Journal of Applied PsychologyLeakage of relevant information to innocent examinees in the GKT: An attempt to reduce false-positive outcomes by introducing target stimuli
Informed innocents showed larger electrodermal responses to critical items than uninformed innocents but smaller than guilty participants. The target stimulus manipulation tended to reduce differences between informed and uninformed innocent… [034] 1999 • SCIENTIFIC STANDARDS Psychology, Public Policy, and LawAdmissibility of Polygraph Tests: The Application of Scientific Standards Post-Daubert
Applied behavioral science concepts of reliability and validity to polygraph admissibility. Argued that accuracy rates are unpredictable and called for mutual language between scientists and courts. [035] 1998 Psychology, Crime and LawThe role of prior expectations in polygraph examiners decisions
Prior expectations produced no discernible effect on polygraph test outcomes when examiners conducted complete examinations including pre-test interviews, suggesting that behavioral information from direct examiner-examinee interaction may counteract confirmation bias… [036] 1998 Journal of Behavioral Decision MakingSeek and ye shall find: Test results are what you hypothesize they are
[037] 1997 PsychophysiologyEffects of items' repetitions and variations on the efficiency of the guilty knowledge test
Similar detection efficiencies were obtained when a single question was repeated 12 times versus when four different questions were each repeated 3 times. Accumulating information across repetitions and physiological measures… [038] 1996 PsychophysiologyIs an apple a fruit? Semantic relatedness as reflected by psychophysiological responsivity
Semantic generalization varied by relationship type: no generalization occurred across coordinate terms (apple/pear), but moderate generalization appeared for superordinates and synonyms, with complete generalization between verbal and pictorial representations of… [039] 1995 PsychophysiologyGeneralization of the orienting response to significant stimuli: The roles of common and distinctive stimulus components
Both common and distinctive features independently affected OR generalization, with distinctive components showing a threshold effect—the first novel element produced a large OR decline, but additional distinctive features had minimal… [040] 1994 Journal of Behavioral Decision MakingThe effects of prior expectations and outcome knowledge on polygraph examiners' decisions
Prior expectations created statistically significant bias in scoring inconclusive polygraph charts, affecting both experienced and inexperienced examiners. However, when physiological evidence clearly contradicted expectations, judgments remained unaffected, suggesting strong objective… [041] 1992 PsychophysiologyThe effect of common versus distinctive stimulus features on electrodermal orientation to significant stimuli
Distinctive features significantly affected electrodermal responsivity (more distinctive features = decreased responding), but common features had no effect—contradicting additive feature-matching model predictions and suggesting mismatch detection drives the orienting response… [042] 1991 Integrative Psychological and Behavioral ScienceClinical judgment and decision-making in CQT-polygraphy
[043] 1991 Integrative Physiological and Behavioral ScienceClinical judgment and decision-making in CQT-polygraphy: A comparison with other pseudoscientific applications in psychology
The CQT decision process is vulnerable to confirmation bias because examiners start with preconceived hypotheses and the lack of well-defined quantification rules allows them to overweigh confirming evidence while disregarding… [044] 1991 International Journal of PsychophysiologyEffects of mental countermeasures on psychophysiological detection in the guilty knowledge test
Item-specific mental countermeasures tended to increase psychophysiological detection, whereas continuous dissociation strategies decreased detection efficiency, with patterns consistent across field and laboratory settings. [045] 1990 Theories and Applications in the Detection of DeceptionLaboratory Studies: Factors Affecting Psychophysiological Detection
[046] 1990 Journal of Experimental Psychology: GeneralNovelty and significance in orientation and habituation: A feature-matching approach
Experiment 2 supported the feature-matching model, showing that effects of novelty and significance were additive rather than interactive. Electrodermal responsivity reflected the degree of habituation to stimulus components, with monotonic… [047] 1990 BookTheories and applications in the detection of deception: A psychophysiological and international perspective
The authors developed a cognitive theoretical framework for understanding psychophysiological deception detection that would profoundly influence subsequent polygraph research and policy debates for decades. [048] 1990 Theories and Applications in the Detection of DeceptionHistory and Description
The chapter documents the evolution of polygraph instrumentation and identifies six major problems with the Control Question Test, establishing a critical framework that distinguished scientifically grounded approaches from commercially driven… [049] 1990 Theories and Applications in the Detection of DeceptionReliability and Validity of Polygraph-Based Classification
Across 10 GKT laboratory experiments, 84% of guilty examinees and 94% of innocent examinees were correctly classified, with accuracy rates highest when tests included more questions. [050] 1990 Theories and Applications in the Detection of DeceptionBeyond Validity: Utility and Legal Considerations in the Application of Psychophysiological Detection
The authors demonstrated that validity alone is insufficient for evaluating polygraph applications—practical utility depends on base rates, differential consequences of errors, stakeholder perspectives, and legal contexts that vary across different… [051] 1990 Theories and Applications in the Detection of DeceptionA Critical Comparison of the Major Methods of Polygraph Interrogation
The GKT/CIT relies on solid scientific principles and incorporates proper control questions with standardized procedures, while the CQT suffers from questionable scientific status, lack of standardization, and dependence on examiner… [052] 1990 Springer-VerlagTheories and Applications in the Detection of Deception
The book establishes that the CQT lacks the scientific foundation necessary for valid testing due to non-equivalent comparison questions, while the GKT offers a scientifically superior alternative based on standardized… [053] 1989 PsychophysiologyEffects of motivation level and verbal response type on psychophysiological detection in the guilty knowledge test
Highly motivated subjects were detected significantly better than less motivated subjects, and the act of lying enhanced differential responsivity. However, no differences emerged between verbal response types or between verbal… [054] 1987 Journal of Experimental Psychology: GeneralCommon and distinctive features of verbal and pictorial stimuli as determinants of psychophysiological responsivity
Skin conductance responses increased monotonically with the number of matching features between test stimuli and relevant memorized items, supporting an automatic feature-matching model of similarity perception rather than simple categorical… [055] 1985 PsychophysiologyStandardization Within Individuals: A Simple Method to Neutralize Individual Differences in Skin Conductance
Within-subject standardization (z-scores) consistently produced superior discrimination between relevant and neutral stimuli compared to range correction methods across all five data sets examined. The standardization method's advantage derives from reliance… [056] 1982 PsychophysiologyThe dichotimization theory for differential autonomic responsivity reconsidered
The reconsidered theory established that stimulus significance is more potent than novelty alone in producing differential electrodermal responses, and that habituation generalizes completely within but not between stimulus categories. The… [057] 1982 • MOCK CRIME/FIELD Journal of Applied PsychologyA Method for Evaluating the Use of the Polygraph in a Real-Life Situation
Innovative Israeli study using real crime scenario with unknown ground truth to evaluate polygraph accuracy. Demonstrated CQT effectiveness in a naturalistic military context. [058] 1982 • MOCK CRIME Journal of Applied PsychologyCQT Lab Accuracy with Community Participants
Used community rather than student volunteers for increased ecological validity. Found accuracy rates comparable to field studies, supporting generalizability of lab results. [059] 1977 PsychophysiologyA further study of the dichotomization theory in detection of information
The study confirmed that critical items elicit larger responses when presented less frequently, and demonstrated 'negative detection' when neutral items became the rare stimulus category, supporting the theory that within-category…Explore all research.
Browse our complete database of 3493 peer-reviewed polygraph studies.